29

Oct

Yes, in certain circumstances, a foreign vessel docked at PortMiami can be arrested or attached under federal admiralty law to help secure a maritime injury claim. However, the legal requirements depend on the type of claim, the relationship between the vessel and the responsible party, and whether the claimant can establish the necessary maritime jurisdiction. Two important procedures are Rule C vessel arrest and Rule B maritime attachment. They serve different purposes and cannot be used interchangeably.

When a foreign-flagged cruise ship, cargo vessel, or commercial craft is preparing to leave Miami, an injured person may have limited time to preserve an opportunity to secure the defendant’s assets. Acting quickly can be important, particularly when the vessel’s owner is based overseas or has limited assets in the United States. An experienced Miami maritime accident lawyer can investigate the ownership structure, evaluate available maritime remedies, and determine whether emergency court action is appropriate.

Why Can Foreign Vessels at PortMiami Create Collection Challenges?

PortMiami is a major international gateway for cruise travel and commercial shipping. Its substantial maritime activity means that injury claims can involve foreign vessel owners, international shipping companies, overseas insurers, and complicated corporate ownership arrangements.

Miami-Dade County reported the following activity for Fiscal Year 2025, which ran from October 1, 2024, through September 30, 2025:

8,564,225
Cruise passengers
1,156
Cruise ship calls
1,115,058
Cargo TEUs
911
Cargo ship calls

Source: Miami-Dade County, PortMiami Fiscal Year 2025 statistics. TEUs are twenty-foot equivalent units, a standard measurement of container cargo volume.

These figures illustrate the scale of international maritime activity in Miami. They also help explain why injury claims involving foreign vessels can present challenges that differ from ordinary Florida personal injury cases.

For example, a vessel may be owned by a foreign corporation, operated by a separate company, and insured through an international Protection and Indemnity (P&I) Club. Identifying the correct defendant and determining which assets are legally available to secure a claim can require substantial investigation.

A vessel’s departure does not automatically eliminate an injured person’s legal rights. However, if a claimant is considering a federal maritime attachment or arrest, the location of the vessel and the timing of service can become important. Once a vessel leaves the district, it may no longer be available for seizure there.

What Is the Difference Between Rule C Vessel Arrest and Rule B Maritime Attachment?

Federal admiralty law provides two distinct procedures that may allow a claimant to seize property before obtaining a final judgment. They are found in the Supplemental Rules for Admiralty or Maritime Claims of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

Rule C provides for an in-rem action against a vessel to enforce a valid maritime lien. Rule B allows a claimant with a qualifying maritime claim against a defendant to attach the defendant’s property when the defendant cannot be found within the federal judicial district.

The distinction matters because an injured person cannot automatically arrest a vessel simply because the shipowner is foreign or the ship is scheduled to depart Miami.

Legal feature Rule C Vessel Arrest Rule B Maritime Attachment
Type of action In rem action against the vessel itself. In personam action against the defendant, supported by attachment of the defendant’s property.
Primary requirement A valid maritime lien against the vessel or an applicable federal statute authorizing an in-rem action. A valid prima facie maritime claim, a defendant who cannot be found within the district, and attachable property belonging to that defendant within the district.
Potential claims Claims involving seamen’s wages, collision damages, qualifying maritime torts, and other claims supported by a maritime lien. Qualifying maritime claims against an absent foreign shipowner or other defendant, including claims that do not independently support an in-rem maritime lien.
Property involved The vessel against which the maritime lien is asserted. The defendant’s attachable property, which may include a vessel or tangible property aboard it.
Result The vessel is arrested and placed in the custody of the U.S. Marshal or other authorized custodian pending release or further court proceedings. The defendant’s property is attached to provide security for the claim and establish quasi-in-rem jurisdiction.

Legal authority: Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Supplemental Rules B, C, and E.

When Can an Injured Person Use Rule C?

Rule C permits an in-rem action to enforce a maritime lien. A maritime lien is a legal interest in a vessel that arises under applicable maritime law or a statute. It is different from an ordinary personal injury claim against a company or individual.

Some maritime injuries and related claims may support a lien against the vessel, depending on the circumstances and applicable law. Examples of potentially lien-supported claims include certain maritime torts involving a vessel, collision damages, and qualifying crew wage claims.

However, a claimant should not assume that every injury aboard a ship automatically creates a maritime lien. For example, a passenger’s negligence claim against a cruise line may be enforceable against the responsible company without necessarily creating a lien against the vessel itself.

The legal team must evaluate the nature of the injury, the vessel’s involvement, the identity of the responsible parties, and the applicable maritime law before seeking a Rule C arrest.

When Can an Injured Person Use Rule B?

Rule B serves a different purpose. It allows a plaintiff with a qualifying maritime claim to attach the defendant’s property when the defendant cannot be found within the federal judicial district where the lawsuit is filed.

For example, imagine a foreign corporation owns a commercial vessel docked at PortMiami. A person injured in a maritime incident brings a qualifying claim against that corporation, but the corporation cannot be found within the Southern District of Florida for purposes of Rule B. If the vessel belongs to that defendant and the other requirements are satisfied, the claimant may seek to attach the vessel under Rule B.

Unlike Rule C, Rule B does not require the claimant to establish a maritime lien against the vessel. The attachment is directed at the defendant’s property to secure the claim, rather than enforcing a lien against the vessel itself.

However, the defendant’s foreign status alone is not sufficient. The claimant must establish that the defendant cannot be found within the district, identify property belonging to that defendant within the district, and satisfy the other requirements of the rule.

How Do You Obtain an Emergency Vessel Arrest or Attachment in Miami?

When a potentially attachable vessel is scheduled to leave PortMiami, an attorney may need to prepare an expedited federal filing. The process is governed by federal admiralty rules and the applicable local procedures of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida.

Although the precise steps depend on whether the claimant seeks a Rule B attachment or Rule C arrest, the general process involves the following:

  1. Investigate the injury and identify the responsible parties. The attorney gathers accident reports, medical records, witness statements, vessel information, ownership records, and other evidence to establish the potential maritime claim.
  2. Determine whether Rule B or Rule C applies. The attorney evaluates whether the injury claim supports a maritime lien or whether attachment of the defendant’s property may be available under Rule B. This includes investigating the vessel’s registered owner and any separate operating or management companies.
  3. Prepare and file a verified federal complaint. A Rule C complaint must identify the vessel with reasonable particularity, be verified, and state that the vessel is or will be within the district. A Rule B complaint must establish the maritime claim and include the required affidavit concerning the defendant’s absence from the district.
  4. Obtain judicial authorization or qualifying emergency process. Under Rule C, the court must authorize the arrest process. Under Rule B, judicial review is ordinarily required, although the rule provides a limited procedure for exigent circumstances when court review is impracticable.
  5. Arrange service of the arrest or attachment process. When the property is a vessel or tangible property aboard a vessel, the process must be delivered to the U.S. Marshal for service. The Marshal executes the process in accordance with the federal rules and applicable local procedures.
  6. Address security and release of the vessel. The vessel’s owner or another interested party may seek release by providing acceptable security. Depending on the circumstances, this may involve a bond or a negotiated Letter of Undertaking from a P&I Club.

Timing can be critical because the vessel must be within the district when the arrest or attachment process is executed. A lawyer may therefore need to coordinate the filing, court authorization, and service arrangements while the vessel remains in port.

Can a Shipowner Release an Arrested Vessel by Posting a Bond or Letter of Undertaking?

Yes. A shipowner or another interested party may seek to release an arrested or attached vessel by providing appropriate security. This can allow the vessel to resume operations while the underlying maritime litigation continues.

One commonly used form of security in commercial maritime disputes is a Letter of Undertaking (LOU) issued by a Protection and Indemnity Club. P&I Clubs provide liability coverage and related services to shipowners and operators, including assistance with certain maritime claims.

An LOU may provide an agreement to satisfy a judgment or settlement up to an agreed amount, subject to its terms and conditions. However, the claimant does not automatically have a right to demand that an insurer issue an LOU, and an insurer’s willingness to provide security depends on the applicable coverage, policy terms, and circumstances.

Other security arrangements may include:

  • Surety bonds: A bond may be provided to secure the claim and permit the vessel’s release.
  • Cash deposits: The owner or another interested party may deposit funds as security when permitted by the court.
  • Negotiated security agreements: The parties may agree to acceptable security arrangements that allow the vessel to continue operating while preserving the claimant’s ability to pursue the case.

The amount and form of security must be addressed under the applicable federal rules and court procedures. An attorney should carefully review any proposed LOU or bond to ensure that it adequately protects the claimant’s interests before agreeing to release the vessel.

How Do Florida Maritime Laws Affect Vessel Arrest and Attachment?

Federal admiralty law is generally the primary framework for maritime claims involving navigable waters. However, Florida statutes may also be relevant, depending on the nature of the incident and the legal issues involved.

Several Florida statutes deserve attention, although they do not replace the requirements of federal Rule B or Rule C proceedings.

Florida Statutes § 327.32: Vessel Operation and Civil Liability

Florida Statutes § 327.32 declares vessels to be dangerous instrumentalities in Florida and requires operators to exercise the highest degree of care to prevent injuries to others.

Importantly, the statute generally confines liability for reckless or careless vessel operation to the operator in immediate charge. The vessel owner may also be liable when the owner is the operator or is present aboard the vessel when the injury or damage occurs.

This statute may be relevant when evaluating liability arising from vessel operation in Florida. It does not, by itself, establish a maritime lien or authorize the arrest of a foreign vessel under federal admiralty law.

Florida Statutes § 48.193: Jurisdiction Over Foreign Businesses

Florida Statutes § 48.193 addresses personal jurisdiction over nonresidents and foreign businesses that engage in specified activities connected to Florida.

For example, the statute addresses conducting business in Florida and committing certain tortious acts within the state. Whether a foreign vessel owner or operating company is subject to Florida jurisdiction depends on the company’s activities, the connection between those activities and the claim, and applicable constitutional requirements.

It is important to distinguish state-court personal jurisdiction from the jurisdictional requirements for a federal admiralty action. Establishing one does not automatically establish the other.

Florida Statutes § 76.04: Grounds for State-Law Attachment

Florida Statutes § 76.04 identifies circumstances in which a creditor may seek an attachment when a debt is actually due. These include circumstances involving fraudulent transfers, the removal of property from Florida, and a debtor’s residence outside the state.

However, this statute is part of Florida’s state-law attachment procedure. It should not be confused with federal maritime attachment under Rule B. The nature of the claim and the applicable procedural requirements determine whether state-law attachment is available.

Florida Statutes § 713.60: Liens for Labor Performed on Vessels

Florida Statutes § 713.60 provides a lien for certain labor, materials, and services performed on or for the benefit of a vessel.

The statute specifically addresses work involving vessel construction, crew members, loading and unloading, and other qualifying services. Depending on the circumstances, a lien created under state law may be enforceable through an admiralty in-rem proceeding.

It does not create a general vessel lien for every person injured aboard a ship. The claimant must establish that the work or services fall within the statute and satisfy the applicable requirements for enforcing the lien.

Understanding how these state statutes interact with federal admiralty law requires careful legal analysis. For more information about this area of practice, visit our page for a Maritime Liens & Vessel Arrest Attorney.

Why Does Experience in Maritime Litigation Matter?

Vessel arrest and maritime attachment proceedings involve specialized legal and practical issues. Attorneys must understand federal admiralty procedure, maritime liens, international vessel ownership, marine insurance, and the operational realities of commercial shipping.

At Brais Law Firm, founding partner Keith S. Brais brings both maritime industry experience and decades of legal practice to the firm’s representation of injured maritime workers and passengers.

  • Marine engineering background: Before practicing law, Keith earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Marine Engineering from Massachusetts Maritime Academy. He also obtained three U.S. Coast Guard engineering licenses and worked aboard offshore oil drilling platforms for more than seven years.
  • Board-certified maritime attorney: Keith has been Board Certified by The Florida Bar in Admiralty and Maritime Law since 1996. Board certification recognizes attorneys who meet the Bar’s requirements for substantial experience, peer review, and demonstrated competence in a particular practice area.
  • Professional recognition: Keith has held an AV Preeminent peer-review rating from Martindale-Hubbell since 2001, according to his professional biography.
  • Maritime litigation experience: Brais Law Firm represents individuals in maritime personal injury, wrongful death, and other complex maritime disputes. The firm’s case results and reported landmark maritime cases provide additional information about its litigation experience.

Keith’s background in marine engineering and offshore operations provides practical insight into vessel operations, shipboard equipment, and the working conditions that can contribute to serious maritime injuries.

For readers who want to understand the broader legal framework governing maritime injury claims, Brais Law Firm also provides A Primer on Maritime Law.

Evidence preservation is another important consideration in maritime injury cases. For example, cruise ship surveillance footage may be overwritten or become unavailable if it is not preserved promptly. Learn more in Surveillance Footage and Cruise Ship Injuries: Your Rights Explained.

What Should You Do if You Are Injured Aboard a Foreign Vessel at PortMiami?

If you or a loved one suffers a serious injury aboard a foreign cruise ship, cargo vessel, yacht, or commercial craft, taking appropriate steps early can help preserve evidence and protect potential legal claims.

  1. Report the injury. Notify the ship’s master, supervisor, medical department, or other appropriate representative. Request that the incident be documented.
  2. Preserve available evidence. Keep photographs, medical records, witness information, incident reports, and communications relating to the accident.
  3. Identify the vessel and its operator. Record the vessel’s name, flag, location, operator, and any available ownership information.
  4. Obtain medical treatment. Seek appropriate medical attention and maintain records of treatment, diagnoses, and related expenses.
  5. Consult a maritime attorney promptly. An attorney can investigate the responsible parties, identify applicable deadlines, and determine whether a maritime lien, Rule B attachment, Rule C arrest, or another legal remedy may be available.

Do not assume that a vessel’s departure eliminates your ability to pursue compensation. However, if the circumstances support an emergency arrest or attachment, delaying legal action could make it more difficult to secure the vessel or other assets within the district.

Speak With a Board-Certified Miami Maritime Attorney

If you or a loved one suffered a serious injury aboard a foreign cruise ship, cargo vessel, yacht, or commercial craft calling on PortMiami, understanding your legal options is important. Depending on the circumstances, federal admiralty law may provide a way to arrest a vessel or attach other property to secure a maritime claim before a final judgment.

The attorneys at Brais Law Firm handle complex maritime injury and vessel-related litigation. Contact the firm at 800-499-0551 or 305-709-4117 to discuss your circumstances and arrange a free, confidential case evaluation.

Disclaimer: This article provides general educational information and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this content or contacting Brais Law Firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Maritime injury claims, vessel arrests, and attachment proceedings involve fact-specific federal and state laws, procedural requirements, and deadlines. Past case results do not guarantee or predict future outcomes. Consult a qualified maritime attorney regarding your particular circumstances.

Back to Blog

National and International All Ports of Call. Anywhere Offshore.
Brais Law is here for you.

Contact Us
Accessibility: If you are vision-impaired or have some other impairment covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act or a similar law, and you wish to discuss potential accommodations related to using this website, please contact our Accessibility Manager at 800-499-0551.